Where the idea comes from
Most Protestant Christians do not pray for the dead, and many associate the practice with purgatory and with the sale of indulgences that helped spark the Reformation. So when they see Orthodox memorial services and hear prayers for the departed, they reasonably assume Orthodoxy teaches purgatory too.
But prayer for the dead is far older than the doctrine of purgatory - and the Orthodox Church kept the first while explicitly rejecting the second.
Praying for the departed is ancient
Faithful Jews prayed for the dead before Christ (2 Maccabees 12:43-45, part of the Old Testament the Orthodox Church reads). Christian tombs in the Roman catacombs ask for prayers for those buried there, and every ancient Christian liturgy includes prayers for the departed.
Orthodox Christians pray for their loved ones because death does not break the communion of the Church. In Christ, 'all live unto him' (Luke 20:38) - and love keeps praying.
Why Orthodoxy rejects purgatory
Purgatory, as defined in the medieval West, teaches that souls must make satisfaction for the temporal punishment still owed for forgiven sins, in a cleansing fire, before entering heaven. At the Council of Ferrara-Florence (1438-1439), St. Mark of Ephesus led the Orthodox objection to this teaching, and the Orthodox Church has never accepted it.
Orthodox theology does not think of forgiveness as a debt that must still be worked off after God has forgiven it. Christ's victory is complete. The Church teaches no fire of purgation, no system of temporal punishment, and no indulgences.
Trusting the departed to God's mercy
What happens between death and the Last Judgment is largely a mystery, and the Orthodox Church is content to leave it so. It teaches that the soul lives on, that the departed already taste something of joy or of sorrow, and that the prayers of the Church are a real help and comfort to them. Beyond that, it does not speculate.
At every Orthodox funeral the Church asks Christ to give the departed rest with the saints. It is a prayer of trust in His love, not a calculation of time served.
With the saints give rest, O Christ, to the soul of Thy servant, where there is neither sickness nor sorrow nor sighing, but life everlasting.
- Orthodox Christians pray for the departed, as the Church always has.
- The Orthodox Church rejects purgatory, temporal punishment and indulgences.
- The state of the soul after death is held as a mystery entrusted to God's mercy.