Where the idea comes from
From the outside, Orthodox and Roman Catholic Christians look alike: bishops and priests, sacraments, saints, incense and a liturgy. Both trace their history to the Apostles. So it is natural to describe Orthodoxy as 'Catholics without the Pope,' or as a branch that split off from Rome in 1054.
The similarities are real, and Orthodox Christians are glad of them. But the shorthand hides genuine differences in doctrine, and it assumes a reading of history the Orthodox Church does not share.
One Church for a thousand years
For the first millennium, East and West were one Church, with five ancient patriarchates: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch and Jerusalem. The Bishop of Rome was honored as first among equals, and disputes were settled by councils of bishops, as the Apostles settled theirs at the Council of Jerusalem (Acts 15).
The estrangement between Rome and the other patriarchates grew over centuries and is traditionally dated to 1054. From the Orthodox point of view, it was Rome that moved away from the shared faith - by claiming authority over the whole Church and by altering the Creed - while the other ancient patriarchates kept the faith as they had received it.
Differences beyond the Pope
The papacy is the largest issue. The Roman Catholic Church teaches that the Pope has universal, immediate jurisdiction over the whole Church and, under certain conditions, teaches infallibly, as defined at the First Vatican Council in 1870. The Orthodox Church teaches that all bishops are equal in their sacramental office, and that the Church is governed by councils, with the first bishop acting only in concert with the others.
Other differences include the Filioque - the Western addition to the Nicene Creed saying that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father 'and the Son' - along with purgatory and indulgences, the dogma of the Immaculate Conception (1854), and different ways of speaking about grace and how God is known.
There are practical differences too. Orthodox priests may be married if they married before ordination, infants receive Chrismation and Communion at their Baptism, the Eucharist is celebrated with leavened bread, and the Orthodox calendar and fasting seasons are distinct.
A family of self-governing churches
Instead of a single head on earth, the Orthodox Church is a communion of self-governing churches - the Patriarchates of Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem, Moscow, Serbia and Romania, the Churches of Greece and Cyprus, and others - united by one faith and one worship. The Ecumenical Patriarch of Constantinople holds a primacy of honor, not of command. Christ alone is head of the Church (Colossians 1:18).
The bishops of every nation must acknowledge him who is first among them and account him as their head, and do nothing of consequence without his consent... But neither let him who is the first do anything without the consent of all.
- Orthodox and Roman Catholics share the first thousand years, the sacraments and apostolic succession.
- They differ on the papacy, the Filioque, purgatory and the Immaculate Conception, among other things.
- Orthodoxy is a communion of self-governing churches led by councils, with Christ as head.