Skip to main content
Common misconception · Worship & the Sacraments

Is Orthodox Worship Just Empty Ritual and Vain Repetition?

What you may have heard

“Orthodox worship is dead ritual - the 'vain repetitions' Jesus warned against.”

What the Orthodox Church actually teaches

No. The Orthodox services are woven almost entirely from Scripture, and repetition in prayer is itself biblical - the living creatures in heaven repeat 'Holy, holy, holy' day and night. What Jesus condemned was trying to manipulate God with many words, not returning to Him again and again.

Where the idea comes from

In Matthew 6:7 Jesus warns, 'When ye pray, use not vain repetitions, as the heathen do.' Christians from traditions that prize spontaneous prayer sometimes hear the Orthodox services - 'Lord, have mercy' sung dozens of times, the same Liturgy every Sunday - as exactly the ritualism Jesus condemned.

It is also true that any kind of worship, liturgical or not, can be done on autopilot. The real question is whether the form itself is the problem.

What Jesus actually warned against

Jesus finishes the sentence: the pagans 'think that they shall be heard for their much speaking.' The problem was not repetition but the belief that piling up words could pressure a god into answering. A moment later Jesus gives His disciples a fixed prayer to say - the Lord's Prayer (Matthew 6:9-13) - and the early Christians prayed it three times a day, as the Didache instructs.

Repetition fills the Bible

Psalm 136 repeats 'for his mercy endureth for ever' twenty-six times. In Gethsemane Jesus 'prayed the third time, saying the same words' (Matthew 26:44). In Revelation the living creatures around God's throne 'rest not day and night, saying, Holy, holy, holy, Lord God Almighty' (Revelation 4:8). The worship of heaven is gloriously repetitive.

Repetition is how love speaks. The tax collector's prayer, 'God be merciful to me a sinner' (Luke 18:13), is the root of the Jesus Prayer, which Orthodox Christians repeat throughout the day as a way to 'pray without ceasing' (1 Thessalonians 5:17).

The Liturgy is Scripture, prayed

Nearly every line of the Divine Liturgy quotes or echoes Scripture: the Psalms, the Beatitudes, the Thrice-Holy Hymn, the Lord's Prayer, Christ's own words at the Last Supper. Anyone who attends the services for a year will have prayed many of the Psalms and heard large portions of the New Testament read aloud.

A fixed liturgy also frees a congregation from depending on one person's mood or creativity. Like a family's well-worn traditions, familiar words free the heart to pray instead of following along. The Apostles prayed this way too, keeping the set hours of prayer they knew from the Temple (Acts 3:1).

In the Church's own words
One word of the publican propitiated God, and one cry of faith saved the thief.
St. John ClimacusThe Ladder of Divine Ascent, Step 28, 7th century
In short
  • Jesus condemned trying to manipulate God with many words, not repetition itself.
  • Scripture is full of repeated prayer, from the Psalms to the worship of heaven.
  • The Orthodox services are woven almost entirely from Scripture.
Questions People Ask Next

The follow-up questions.

Once the first misunderstanding is cleared up, these are the questions that usually come next.

Why is 'Lord, have mercy' repeated so often?

Because it may be the most complete prayer a person can pray. Kyrie eleison asks for God's mercy, compassion and loving-kindness all at once. Repeated slowly, it becomes less a request than a way of resting in God's presence.

Isn't a long, unfamiliar service hard to follow?

At first, yes. Most newcomers find that within a few weeks the words become familiar, and familiarity turns into freedom. Service books with the full text are usually available at the back of the church.

Do Orthodox Christians ever pray in their own words?

Of course. The Church's written prayers are a school of prayer, not a cage. Orthodox Christians are encouraged to bring their own needs, thanks and loved ones to God in their own words alongside the prayers of the Church.

The Sunday letter

Orthodox wisdom in your inbox each Sunday

One short email a week: the feasts and saints ahead, practical guides for prayer and fasting, and plain answers to the questions people ask about Orthodoxy.

We respect your time and privacy - unsubscribe anytime.

Come and see

The best answer is a Sunday morning.

No page can show you the Orthodox Church as well as the Divine Liturgy can. Visit a parish, stay for coffee hour, and ask the priest anything.