Where the idea comes from
The Letter to the Hebrews insists that Christ offered Himself 'once for all' (Hebrews 10:10), unlike the Old Testament priests who offered sacrifices day after day. When Protestant Christians hear the Orthodox call the Eucharist a sacrifice, offered on an altar by a priest, it can sound like a denial of that finished work.
Many of these concerns were shaped by Reformation-era debates over the Roman Catholic Mass. The Orthodox Church was not part of those debates, and its understanding is best heard in its own words.
One sacrifice, not many
The Orthodox Church affirms Hebrews without reservation: Christ's offering on the Cross was once for all and is complete. Nothing needs to be added to it, and it can never be repeated. St. John Chrysostom, whose Liturgy Orthodox Christians celebrate most Sundays, preached on exactly this point: the Church always offers the same sacrifice, so the sacrifice is one.
Christ is the one who offers
During the Cherubic Hymn the priest prays quietly to Christ: 'For Thou art the Offerer and the Offered, the Receiver and the Distributed, O Christ our God.' The priest is not a second sacrificer standing beside Christ. Christ Himself is the true High Priest (Hebrews 4:14), and the earthly priest serves His one priesthood.
The Liturgy calls itself a 'reasonable and bloodless worship.' The Church, gathered into Christ, offers back to God what He has given: 'Thine own of Thine own we offer unto Thee, on behalf of all and for all.'
A remembrance that makes present
When Jesus said, 'This do in remembrance of me' (Luke 22:19), the Greek word was anamnesis - a remembering that makes a past saving event present, the way the Passover meal brought every generation of Israel into the Exodus. In the Liturgy the Church is not reenacting Calvary or adding to it. The faithful are gathered to the one Cross and the empty tomb.
That is why St. Paul calls the cup and the bread a true 'communion of the blood of Christ' and 'communion of the body of Christ' (1 Corinthians 10:16). Orthodox Christians believe the bread and wine truly become Christ's Body and Blood - not because He is sacrificed again, but because the risen Lord gives Himself to His people.
We offer always the same, not one sheep now and tomorrow another, but always the same thing: so that the sacrifice is one.
- Christ's sacrifice was once for all and can never be repeated.
- In the Liturgy the Church shares in that one offering; Christ is the true offerer.
- Orthodox Christians receive His true Body and Blood in Communion.