Where the idea comes from
Many Protestants were taught that because Christ is our one mediator, Christians should confess their sins directly to God with no one in between. The image of a priest hearing confession - often borrowed from film scenes of a Catholic confessional booth - suggests a human gatekeeper standing between the sinner and God's forgiveness.
Orthodox confession looks and feels quite different. There is usually no booth. The penitent stands before an icon of Christ, often with the priest beside them rather than facing them, and the words of the service make clear who is really hearing the confession.
Christ receives the confession
In a widely used form of the service, the priest begins: 'Behold, my child, Christ stands here invisibly and receives your confession... I am but a witness.' Orthodox Christians confess directly to God - in their daily prayers and in the sacrament alike. In the sacrament they simply do it with a witness, as Scripture urges.
St. James writes, 'Confess your faults one to another, and pray one for another, that ye may be healed' (James 5:16). In the early Church confession was often made publicly, before the whole congregation. Confessing privately, with a priest as witness, grew out of that practice as a pastoral mercy.
An authority Christ gave the Church
After the Resurrection, Christ breathed on the apostles and said, 'Receive ye the Holy Ghost: Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them' (John 20:22-23). The Church understands this as a real authority entrusted to its shepherds.
Even so, the prayer of absolution asks God to do the forgiving: 'May our Lord and God, Jesus Christ, through the grace and bounties of His love toward mankind, forgive you, my child, all your transgressions.'
A hospital, not a courtroom
Orthodox Christians often call confession a hospital rather than a courtroom. The same exhortation warns the penitent: since you have come to a physician, do not leave unhealed. The priest may offer counsel, or a small spiritual exercise to help - never a payment for sins Christ has already forgiven.
Hearing a fellow Christian, bound by the strictest confidentiality, speak the words of forgiveness aloud is a gift. Many Orthodox Christians describe walking out of confession lighter than they have felt in years.
Behold, my child, Christ stands here invisibly and receives your confession. Therefore be not ashamed, neither be afraid... I am but a witness, bearing testimony before Him of all things which you say to me.
- In confession the penitent confesses to Christ; the priest is a witness and guide.
- Forgiveness comes from God alone, through the ministry He entrusted to His Church.
- Confession is spiritual healing, not a legal transaction.